Board Thread:Antaeus' Arena: Audience Chamber/@comment-4531192-20140124213432/@comment-4737110-20140130081355

Annabeth has a lot more experience and technical skill than Percy, but Percy is more powerful. Power does not, however, guarantee a win in a fight.

It would be quite evenly matched in this case, because Annabeth and Percy know each others' strengths and weaknesses.

Annabeth has a knife which is a close range weapon, which means she would have to get in close, but even if she lost her knife, she seems to know martial arts as well as being fast and agile.

Percy has a sword which is a long range weapon, which means that it would be difficult for Annabeth to close the distance between them. If Percy lost his sword, he has his water powers, provided there is water around, but his sword comes back anyway.

If Annabeth managed to get in close, she would have the upper hand because of her weapon and proximity to him means she could go martial arts ninja on his behind.

But as we know, Percy is an excellent swordsman, and to get in that close would be difficult. Plus he has hurricane powers...

I can't pick this one, but here are some factors for you to think about!