Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-25014849-20140627232456/@comment-1820614-20150425014704

I rank Annabeth low because in purely battle terms nothing she brings really outshines the others except for Piper. Yes, she might be a better at straight combat at using weapons, but Percy and Jason are her superiors in that. Frank and Nico are supposed to be pretty good warriors on their own. Frank's shapeshifting was proven to be very useful in combat. Nico can bury his enemies in the Earth or summon undead soldiers. The only time I recall she got the better of Percy was when he was still new to camp.

Finally, I'm not sure how much her intelligence would be useful in the middle of a battle. As was pointed out, Nyx and other immortals (godly and monster) tend to be kind of stupid.