Board Thread:Antaeus' Arena: Audience Chamber/@comment-1515612-20150930233157/@comment-24067344-20160812144644

Commander Tool Belt wrote: We are the ones staging the fight, and it honestly would only be fair if all elements are present.

Lol imagine if Percy takes a water bottle to every battle. It would be his nectar.

You are so right. In The Lightning Theif, Percy was doused with a bucket of icy water...and you know what happened? He got like twice as strong, and was able to defeat Luke in swordsmanship class. I'm guessing even a water bottle would be enough to reinvigorate him.

@MajickPizza: If we go by feats and fights, like the Mark of Athena example you gave us, Percy would be superior by far. So, if we go by that, Jason would lose. The best we can do is not mention fights and feats, for we know Percy defeats Jason in that category. It's not a good measure of thinking which one is better in combat.