Board Thread:Antaeus' Arena: Audience Chamber/@comment-1515612-20150915042350/@comment-5471249-20150915181150

A pretty tough one, I'll admit...

Jason--has been training at CJ for 12 years, held his own against Enceladus, Otis, Ephialtes, defeated Krios, and even defeated Porphyrion, albeit with assistance from Zeus. Fought evenly against an experienced Percy while mind-controlled, and was only defeated and wounded after Piper momentarily distracted him....

Luke--was able to survive out in the open for several years on his own in his early teens, with nothing but a golf club as a makeshift weapon. Annabeth describes him as "an amazing monster-fighter, even without training", and with training he became the best swordsman of Camp Half-Blood in the last 300 years, easily managing to defeat Percy in "The Sea of Monsters"... However, that was a weaker and less skilled version of Percy, while Jason held his own against an experienced one...

I feel like  Luke should get a slight edge in swordsmanship, since he's several years older and more experienced.