Board Thread:Antaeus' Arena: Audience Chamber/@comment-4547258-20150619201200/@comment-4902593-20150621060556

Lets break this down:

Race:

Carter is a 100% human. A demigod is 50% mortal and 50% god. Demigods are more strong and powerful compared to mortals, as in, they do not suffer too much from physical injuries, and have higher strength and stamina.

And Percy is a son of Big Three, which is the highest and most powerful demigod type. That automatically gives him a huge advantage over Carter. I mean, even with all his magical training, Carter was lagging behind Percy.

Combat Training:

Percy has more years of training and experience. Carter is only a newbie. I ask you, what are Carter's noteworthy feats? He defeated Set, relying mostly on Horus' powers. He didn't beat the Tjesu Heru, and he got beaten by the Serapis Bull. Percy, on the other hand, has a shopping list of feats.

Powers:

I admit, the HoO screwed up Percy's power potential. But still Percy Jackson is extremely powerful.

Carter can only summon a combat avatar, enhance physical attacks and do a few basic spells. He sucks at hieroglyphics. He may be the second most powerful magician in the world, but that is nothing compared to the guy who made Mt St Helens explode and awaken Typhon.

Not sure of this whole blood bending gig though.

Personality:

Carter's personality is pretty cool. But Percy takes it to a whole new level. Also, Percy is much better at explaining things in simple terms than Annabeth. And he can intimidate pretty much any other demigod.

Conclusion:

In a duel between them, although Carter would give a good fight, Percy would defeat him eventually. The only way Carter can win over Percy is when he is in the Eye of Horus mode, although he wouldn't hold it for long.