User blog comment:SayuriDarling/The Demigod Diaries Official Discussion Blog/@comment-4430596-20120817023524

This was a great book.

First, we have The Diary of Luke Castellan. This book really gave some more reason to Luke's actions, and made his character seem more human. It also had a nice explanation of how Thalia got Aegis. Also, it had a great story, I particuarly liked it when they made Greek Fire.

Next, Percy Jackson and the Staff of Hermes. This was acctually my least favorite story, although it was still good. I thought Cacus was an uninteresting villian. However, it had some great dialouge with Geroge, Martha, and Hermes. I also liked how Hermes ssaid Janus was working in television, causing all the cancelled shows.

Next, Leo Valdez and the Quest for Buford. This was a great story. Leo was an excellent narrarator, the Maeneds intriguing villans, and Buford, the incredible wakling table was a superb character. Need I say more?

Finally, The Son of Magic. This story was very different from any of the others, or indded any of the Camp Half-Blood books. This can be chalked up to the difference of writers. I though Haley Riordan proved himself to be a very good writer. I enjoyed his style immensly. I thought having the majority of the story being told by Claymore was a refreshing change of pace. While the plot was not exceptional, the characters were, driving the story to greatness.