Board Thread:Antaeus' Arena: Audience Chamber/@comment-1515612-20161222000051/@comment-29377413-20161224001616

Well of course piper can charmspeak leo why else were we arguing about the earmuffs? While I do like and enjoy reading your long arguements, I just want to say that none of us said that if your female your immune to charmspeak. We didnt even mention gender at all. Charmspeak does work on females it's just since piper is a girl and not a lot of girls are attracted to girls, they just have a more chance of resisting. Like in one of the quotes you said, Khione wasnt fooled at all.

We have also never said pipers charmspeak wouldnt work on leo (hence the earmuff arguement) just that since he has the requirments that make charmspeaking someone somewhat harder to control, piper may have difficulty.

So lets say piper does say stop and leo does stop... What then? If she charges then shes not controlling him anymore making it easier for leo to break out of the spell. This senario has been said, but this is just a reminder. As soon as leo breaks out, piper is still charging so he can take the time to put on his ear muffs and proceed to fight piper.