Board Thread:Antaeus' Arena: Audience Chamber/@comment-1515612-20161222000051/@comment-25155763-20170304183534

Ea225225 wrote:

Oceanhalo12 wrote:

Ea225225 wrote:

Oceanhalo12 wrote: ^Why wouldn't she do that to all her opponents then? Seriously you guys are over-exaggerating her powers.If she could tell her opponents to pass out or roll on the floor crying, she would've done so. The most she's done is yell 'stop!' or 'miss!' which only lasted for a couple of seconds. Dude, how are we over exaggerating her powers?!? Charmspeaking all she has to do. All she has to say is "stop", it won't take seconds, when she charmspeaked the car dealer to give her a car, PRETTY SURE THAT WILL NOT TAKE SECONDS!!! So stop saying that. A.)First and foremost, you don't tell me what to do. I will say what I want, when I want, and however many times I want.

B. Your over exaggerating because If she could just tell her opponents to stop, she would've done it already.There's only two reasons why she wouldn't tell her opponent to stop ever before. Either she can't do it, or she doesn't know she can do it, honestly,by all means take your pick. But what about this fight would change either of those things? If you have a reason-do tell.

C. That car thing was against a mortal, who literally can't process the existence of charmspeak through the mist, much less protect themselves against it.Very different than a fight against a boy who's known her for like 2 years(Maybe more we don't really know what exactly was fake memories), a boy who knows about her charmspeak, a boy who is unnatracted to her.

D. What you need to stop doing is using the car thing as an example. That was one time that was just a memory-we don't even know specifics. We've seen her use her charmspeak much mo re  times than that,so that's what I'm going to base my opinion-which means that her charmspeak usually last a maximum of like eleven seconds. And you using caps lock or exclamation points isn't gonna change that. Dude, your acting as if you haven't done it yourself. You too have once said the phrase "stop saying that" too in this thread on reply#47. And I can look at a bunch of threads where you have once used caps lock and exclamation points. Also, what your saying about her not saying "stop" is so false. She said it a bunch of times with her charmspeak in MOA(when Percy and Jason were fighting) You also haven't said anything when I said multiple times that Leo was charmspeaked by Piper easily, sure he still has a resistance no doubt, but it's proven that Leo can fall helpless with her charmspeak. Also, it's a surprise you're still debating when you just said it was draw in your earlier replies. No actually, I said "Leo is not my favorite so stop saying that. Very different than your "PRETTY SURE THAT WILL NOT TAKE SECONDS!!! So stop saying that".

Obviously, I've used Caps Lock and exclamation points, they exist to be used-for emphasis though, not for screaming to stop saying that.

And please, tell me how well it worked in MoA? Obvi it works against Jason-he's her boyfriend. But it proved to be very ineffective against Percy. Even we it did work-the book made it clear she was controlling the Eidolon, not Percy. Because Percy has Annabeth. And Leo has Calypso-we get further proof of him getting 'over' Piper/Hazel/Reyna when Hazel mentions he's been less flirtatious and that she thinks he's in love. And about the stop thing,she also tried to do it against Medea I believe..which subsequently failed and she had to trick Medea into admitting her plan.