Board Thread:Antaeus' Arena: Audience Chamber/@comment-1515612-20180222213908/@comment-31877829-20180520114421

VishwaUser wrote: Percy and Thalia are both physically strong and skilled. They both have powers and great fighting experience. However, I feel Percy is better at high-pressure high-stakes battles compared to Thalia.

Percy managed to keep his head:

- against Procrustes as a twelve-year old boy

- against the Nemean lion

-against Kronos at Olympus

- disarmed and practically alone, against Chrysaor and his band of pirates (with some team support)

Thalia:

- almost got the Ophiotaurus killed under Luke's manipulations

- wasn't able to dodge Hera's statue at Olympus (this might be Hera's fault but not clearly specified)

- got owned by a bound and gagged Reyna

- didn't perform to her full potential against Orion (I strongly believe she is stronger than Hylla and Reyna)

Going by these feats, I'd vote for Percy. I think that thalia would win since first, she controls lightning and she has a bow and arrows which outweighs percy's sword in ranged combat, and is slightly more nimble and agile so she can avoid. And Renya is actually much stronger than Thalia.