Board Thread:Antaeus' Arena: Audience Chamber/@comment-1515612-20171005135052/@comment-33340147-20171022090538

VidiaPhoenix wrote: This fight all depends on whether Jack is allowed or not. Some have said he was allowed on some forums but not allowed on others.

You guys should really make a policy about Jack and Magnus is fights or just specify when creating a fight if Magnus has Jack to begin with.

For now, I'll say Annabeth because:

-She is the daughter of a war goddess. By instinct, like Clarisse, she is a wonderful fighter. I mean, she was able to fight closely with Percy when he had the Curse of Achilles, nearly keeping up. While other demigods died in the war, she wasn't even injured until she purposefully threw her body in front of Percy to protect him from his own blunder. That alone speaks wonders of her fighting skills. She was also able to block an attack from Kronos while half-dead. Even if Luke was holding him back, it is very impressive.

-She is also experienced. She has been fighting and outsmarting monsters since she was 7. Magnus started, what, a few months ago? A year?

-A strategist. I know it's one thing to say she's a strategist, but remember: Athena herself picked Annabeth to be the leading strategist against the Titan invasion of New York. Athena even confided in Annabeth plans she didn't tell others (except Hermes to deliver the message).

-Cap of Invisibility. It's hard to call. Against Magnus, it'd work. However, I'm not sure about Jack. As someone said, Jack has no eyes and does not see the way humans do. So, I guess whether she is invisible to Jack or not depends on what magic the cap is using to make her invisible. You said that the outcome of the fight depends on whether Jack is not included or not here. And now you say that Annabeth wins whether Jack is included or not. I don't see any messages in between them. And no, Jack doesn't actually act as an extraordinary fighter, even an extraordinary fighter would find it hard to disarm a group of armed dwarves from whole of Nidavellir before you could say a word. (Magnus says so in his POV. I forgot the word).