Board Thread:Antaeus' Arena: Audience Chamber/@comment-1515612-20170817151724/@comment-31094009-20170817163520

So Luke at this time would also have the curse right,

Well then in that case it would definitely be Luke, if he doesn't have the curse than it would be Percy.

As for HoO it would definitely be Luke, even if Percy strengthened his water powers, he has also been shown to doubt himself more whereas I don't think we ever see Luke doubt himself.

However with powers and both without the curse Percy would win as Luke has no magical powers that would help him in combat.