Board Thread:Antaeus' Arena: Audience Chamber/@comment-1515612-20150915042350/@comment-24067344-20150918213331

Kronos300 wrote: Luke defeated Percy several times in combat. Jason wouldn't even have time to react if he got attacked by Luke. You have to consider, that Luke defeated Percy in combat years ago, when he was a very underdeveloped swordsman. Over the years, Percy has significantly improved his sword fighting skills. We do not know if Luke can defeat Percy, or Percy can defeat Luke. And no, if Luke was alive, that wouldn't give Luke a major advantage, because Percy Has been in the Real world, for many years, just like Luke meaning, that even thought Luke is older than Percy, does not certainly mean that Luke is better, as Percy has gotten a ton of experience in the real world in the past years, Especially very Dangerous ones, like Tartarus. Plus, like DarkCloud mentioned so long ago, Luke and Percy will reach a point, where they would not get better at sword fighting. Percy has already reached that point. Even if you train and train, you can't simply get better just by training. You have to battle huge and skilled monsters, Gods, and Swordsman to get better. For example, if Percy could battle against Ares every day, he would get a lot better. But if he just trains at Camp Half Blood, he won't get better as fast as he would with Ares, considering that He has reached a point where Percy is better than everyone at Sword Fighting in Camp Half Blood. So my point is, If Luke was alive, he certainly would've reached a point where he wouldn't get better, like Percy. So if Luke was alive, we simply don't know who would win.