Board Thread:Antaeus' Arena: Audience Chamber/@comment-1515612-20150930233157/@comment-24055022-20151004012502

This isn't a matter of who would do better under circumstances. It's a matter of who did do better. That's definitely Percy. Sure, Jason had crappy luck, being taken when he was 4 and given to Camp Jupiter, but as you said, he had 12 years of training, Percy had 5. Jason had twice as much training as Percy and Percy still fought him on an equal (if not, better) level.

Percy wins. I totally agree with you, and I am impressed as well. But I believe Jason was taken from Hera at 2 years old, not 4.