Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-24252521-20171123044845/@comment-33040002-20171201120701

Oceanhalo12 wrote: Guilt doesn't take away the fact that she had the idea. And it was considered far more than a second. Also considered letting her father die in TLH. So that's four deaths she's considered. You don't think that's abnormal?

You can scroll through http://riordan.wikia.com/wiki/Thread:143737 for a full description of why Piper is heavily unlikable. I know guilt doesn't take away that she had the idea but again she is human and humans make mistakes but what makes you better is that you recognize this mistakes, feel bad for them and don't make them again. That's what Piper does and that's why i don't think she is so bad how some people think. You don't like her okay that's your opinion and that's mine.

And you accuse her to consider to thinking in let her father die but the situation with her father was complicated so what she should make in that situation? she should betray Jason, Leo and Camp Half-Blood, let Gaea destroy the world to save her father that is one person that she loves but just one person compared with the whole world? She wasn't the only hero in Riordan series to be comfronted by this choice and wasn't the only one to get confused about what choice makes.

And you said that were four people but i just remember the situation wiht percy and in the boatI in MoA. In TLH  i just showed my opinion : in any moment she thinks about save Jason over her friends, she stays divided between the idea in betraying everyone and let her father dies.