Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-24252521-20171123044845/@comment-33295654-20180117173421

Oceanhalo12 wrote: Guilt doesn't take away the fact that she had the idea. And it was considered far more than a second. Also considered letting her father die in TLH. So that's four deaths she's considered. You don't think that's abnormal?

You can scroll through http://riordan.wikia.com/wiki/Thread:143737 for a full description of why Piper is heavily unlikable. It's not what you first think, but how you react after that makes you a good or bad person. She thought it and then thought, "No. That's bad, I'm wrong and I'm sorry for thinking like that, I've changed my mind."

If somebody thinks like that it shows they are capable of showing remorse and feeling guilty for something they've done and THAT shows who they are as a person, not their initial feeling.