Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-24252521-20171123044845/@comment-27320292-20180407214248

Lostofme wrote: No, I mean, I'm not even going to respond anymore, this will be last.

Jane wasn't straight b****. Those things were just Piper's narrow minded thoughts.This is similar, just like she thoughts that every being who loves her is good and other ones are evil.

She doesn't need to, but her mentality is still wrong, I mean she steals stuff because she is wanting attention from his dad, if she wants a positive attention, she does need to don't steal things.

Rachel yes, does art because she loves it, we never say that she does art because she wants attention, we said that Piper could've done something like Rachel, ıf she wants attention.

And, end of the discussion. I'm still going to reply, even if you don't. And I'm seriously questioning why you're in anything Piper-related if you dislike her to the point you're defending JANE of all characters.

So we'll break the scene down, shall we? We do know, for a fact, that Jane smiled and held up a plane ticket. Without Piper bias this is certain. Why the hell did she smile? The only reason I can think of is she was trying to be reassuring, but if that was the case she did a poor job of it. And if she was trying to be reassuring, why did she hold up the plane ticket? It looks like she's mocking Piper. And if the smile was going to be reassuring, it would've at least held some warmth, and usually warm smiles aren't described as cold.

And Piper thinks every being who loves her is good and everyone who doesn't is bad? Did you forget that in Mark of Athena she said she didn't hate Reyna?

And she's at a point where ANY attention is good enough for her because it's been going on long enough that Piper is desperate. Her dad is gone so often. Can't acknowledge what you're kid did if you're not even there, can you?

Philo implied that Rachel tried to get attention from her dad by doing art, which is false. She pretty much never got attention from her family by doing art, they didn't give a carp, but she got attention from other people. Piper wants her dad's attention, not other people's attention.