Board Thread:Antaeus' Arena: Audience Chamber/@comment-4531192-20131127130843/@comment-15861170-20131128132407

I think the general consensus is that Thalia would win, but there are a couple of kinks.

1) They wouldn't even fight in the first place.

2) Thalia is afraid of hights. If they were fighting on say, a cliff, Jason would have the advantage.

3) He is a roman. Like in the Reyna vs. Annabeth battle, roman's are trained to fight in groups. In all of his battles, he was working with other demigods. You do the math. What happens when you put him on solo.

4) Thalia is immortal. How did we miss this?

Thalia wins. Plain and simple. There are more odds in her favor. (Not to sound like a Hunger Games geek or anything. :)