Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-24252521-20171123044845/@comment-27320292-20180408020445

Lostofme wrote: Okay, so, it is pointless and a childish thing to do, but here goes,

I never said I dislike Piper, I, yes, dislike her characterization and I explained reasons before; She is flawed character but no one mentions it and they always see her as a flawless person, If any of her friends called about her mistakes or flaws, I could've like her characterization, because this could've made her more realistic.

I'm not defending Jane, I'm saying that she is not just straight b****, like you said. No one can be just straight b***, so, no. Jane was and is not too. And Drew is not too, or other characters who doesn't like Piper or antagonists are not just straight b**** too. They are characters, they're not  just one- dimensional straight up b****.

Don't get me starting on that Reyna-Jason-Piper thing, no. I'm not going to discuss about this with you.

Desperate enought too? Waow... drama and overracting much? I mean, yes, she was in the sad situation but desperate enough to stealing things from getting any kind of attention...? What?

Yes, Philo couldn't maybe explain it well, since she was said herself that her English isn't that good, but the thing is what we are trying to explain here is, this;

Piper could've done something like usefull and a good thing. She could've done anything rather than stealing things. I analyzed the scene without Piper bias and simply put with what we are given Jane is, well, maybe not a b**** but she has yet to show any likable traits, even when you cut out Piper's bias. And well, Drew is another matter because we have evidence she treats her fellow cabin members badly, not just Piper.

Yeah let's not dip into the weird triangle. I don't have the stamina for that.

And it's implied that the situation has been going on for a long time. And yes, some kids do take things to get their parent's attention, it doesn't make it right, but it's a thing that happens. Also it's not technically stealing by definition because she explicitly stated she returns the things. Stealing is defined as "take (another person's property) without permission or legal right and without intending to return it."

I will say she could have focused more on finding other outlets for her feelings, but she does suffer consequences when she takes it too far. No I am not making up her suffering consequences, I can find samples from The Lost Hero of her suffering consequences because of her actions.