Board Thread:The Heroes of Olympus/@comment-27091614-20151023205843/@comment-25155763-20160701184114

8th Hero of Olympus wrote:

Commander Tool Belt wrote: We did this fight twice on Riordan wiki, and guess who won? That's right. Percy Jackson. So what? That was only so because Percy is the more popular character among fans (as some of these fight on Riordan wiki's Anteus Arena ultimately boil down to popularity contests), so that already gives Percy an unfair predisposition towards winning this, without it necessarily being the logical outcome of such a confrontation between the two of them. I beg to differ do you see the replies on the Anteus arena? Most are thoughtful and carefully considered, plenty of users (Including me) researching and making bullet list etc, genuinely trying to find out who would win, there's only a few users who see it as a popularity contest.