Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-24252521-20171123044845/@comment-27320292-20180704044725

Ryan187591 wrote: How does Piper have more heart? She almost let Jason kill Percy. Wait... are you talking about the Percy/Jason jousting session in MoA? It's not explicitly confirmed in that scene that Piper was thinking "You must choose one. Why not let Jason kill him?" of her own volition. This is later reinforced when the eidolon possessing Percy says to her "You have not chosen. So this one will die." Besides, she didn't hesitate because those words swayed her, she couldn't find her voice which usually happens when people are scared. (which it's totally understandable that she's scared, considering what's happening)