Board Thread:Antaeus' Arena: Audience Chamber/@comment-1515612-20160820001629/@comment-38511280-20190729101451

Obviously, Percy would lose if there was no water. He would probably lose to any powerful demigod that way. It should really be what would happen in a place with limited water (a field does have some water), which is where they would probably fight. (Nico is not stupid enough to try to fight in an ocean). Although Percy doesn't need that much water, he's still more powerful in an ocean. Nico might have formal training but Percy doesn't need any, he is probably more still skilled with his powers. (In this case, skill basically is power, you don't really need a lot of control with this.) So, Percy would probably still win.