Board Thread:Antaeus' Arena: Audience Chamber/@comment-1515612-20161222000051/@comment-25155763-20170130202509

MarcakidofHermes wrote: Piper can just walk towards him and pull out her sword while talking. Also What book and what page did it say that? Can't charmspeak and fight? I distinctly remember Piper fighting monsters and telling them to miss.

What your saying doesn't make sense. Piper charmspeaked people without even realizing. Also. Blood of Olympus page 403:

"A huge sword sliced across her path. Compared to her sparring practice with Hazel, the strike was ridiculously low. Piper leaped over the blade and zigzagged toward Annabeth, who was still kicking and writhing in Periboia's grip. Piper had to free her friend.

Unfortunately, the giantess seemed to anticipate her plan.

" I think not, demigod!" Periboia yelled. "This one bleeds!"

The giantess raised her knife.

Piper screamed in charmspeak: "Miss!"

One last thing. Cannot charmspeak and fight? Dude. I said Piper will win the moment it starts. You said she will charmspeak and fight. The match just started. The match literally just started.

Point out where exactly does it say Piper can't fight and charmspeak. I think you made that up

OK THIS is the last thing lol. So since you confidently say you countered all my points and I ask what points and you gave me that one point then counter this.

What if Piper just tell Leo to throw away his pack. Since when is Piper intelligent enough to do that? In any fight, she's always stop "Stop"! or "Miss!", rather than telling her opponent to throw away their weapon, so clearly she's not smart enough to do that. And in your quote, didn't the charmspeak wear off immediately? Yes. Hadn't Piper stopped moving? Yes. My point wasn't that she can't charmspeak during a fight, but that she can't charmspeak while fighting. Two different thing, my friend.