Board Thread:Antaeus' Arena: Audience Chamber/@comment-1515612-20150930233157/@comment-4902593-20151003113212

8th Hero of Olympus wrote: Percy only defeated Hyperion with the Curse of Achilles, while without it, he was almost defeated by the weakest Titan (Iapetus). Jason, on the other hand, while without the curse, defeated a stronger Titan (Krios). Well, Percy was also really weak at the time he fought Iapetus. His shoulder was injured badly.

As for the fight, Jason has like twelve years of training, has gone on some quests and participated in the Titan War, although his fight with Krios is yet to be eleborated. He is also the Son of Jupiter, so that should make him decently powerful.

As for Percy, he is the Son of Poseidon and he has shown crazy instances of his powers. Plus he is way too experienced in fighting monsters and he is one of the three demigods who have been to Tartarus and back. And also he is very skilled in fighting.

While I am tempted to say Percy would win, we can't dismiss Jason as his past in Camp Jupiter has not been elaborated. Still, I have read more about Percy before Jason...

So out of character preference, I say Percy would win.