Board Thread:Antaeus' Arena: Audience Chamber/@comment-1515612-20161222000051/@comment-29267707-20161223205709

Gaea wasn't attracted to Piper. Gaea was also ready for it at the final battle and telling her to stop remember?

Piper has done this before. She charmspeaked people without even thinking.

Leo has succumbed to charmspeak. Can you imagine he wants to kill his best friend. Form of persuasion. It's control right there. He was gonna kill Jason when Medea controlled him. His best friend.

Leo is not immune to charmspeak. It doesn't matter even if he's prepared. The primordial goddess, the Earth itself, was ready for it. She was telling her to stop. Gaea was resisting it at the final battle. But Piper knocked her out with her voice.

Leo has to think of the item he wants. He has to get it from his pack, then put it on. Piper just has to speak. And you telling me Leo is somehow able to think less than a second all that plans and procedures he has to do, where's Piper's instinct is to charmspeak people, even to the point where she doesn't even realize she's charmspeakin people?

So what if Piper is the strongest. Shes still a good person who cares about her friends. Someone made a rant about her caring too much about Jason and considering killing Percy.

Please. You would do the same. Percy was a complete stranger to Piper. It was in the heat of the moment where she was forced to choose who should die. All she did was thought about it. She didnt actually do it. All of you would do the same. Your first thought would be to protect the one you most cared about.

This is the first time I hear Leo is immune to charmspeak. Preparedness or not, if Gaea couldnt fight it, neither can Leo. Plus, Leo's reaction time is too slow. He cant possibly plan all that and not hear Piper at all.