Board Thread:Antaeus' Arena: Audience Chamber/@comment-1515612-20150930233157/@comment-5471249-20160706115959

Commander Tool Belt wrote: What are you talking about? Jason was protecting Piper when he was knocked out by a brick, and trust me, if Percyvwas hit with a brick while protecting Annabeth he would not pass out. Rather, he would do something ten times worse to the thrower of the brick.

Are we really comparing Percy's love for Annabeth to Jason's love for Piper? Because that is a dead argument. You appear to be blowing Percy's durability out of proportion, as there is no way of knowing that Percy wouldn't have gotten knocked out by a brick, even if he was protecting Annabeth at the time. As for Percabeth vs Jasper being a dead argument? Not really, as again, this is a matter of subjective opinion and preference, and since I really dislike Percabeth, I most definitely consider Jason's love for Piper superior - he might not have had the chance to refuse immortality for her, but there's no way to prove that Jason wouldn't have done so, had he been in Percy's position, and I think if would be logical to assume that Jason would have done the same thing.