Board Thread:Antaeus' Arena: Audience Chamber/@comment-1515612-20150102062028/@comment-24067344-20150112205202

PoseidonEpicness45 wrote: You can't beg people to side with someone we don't think will win. Personally I think Athena would win, that is just my opinion. I have nothing against Poseidon, if this was any other fight that included Poseidon I would vote for him (with a few exceptions). You also can't use the argument that Poseidon tipped the scales with Typhon, because even a single grain of rice can tip a scale (I don't mean only a grain of rice was needed with Typhon, it is just an example). You also can't use the argument that Poseidon beat Polybotes, who is a giant. If you read BoO, you could see the giants were HILARIOUSLY easy to beat. I am not saying Poseidon is weak, there are plenty of situations that prove his power. This is just my opinion, not trying to offend anyone. About the giants,They were super easy to beat, but what if RR made them look weaker?In Mythology wasn't the Second war(The Giant war)Even worse than the First Titan War? The gods barely survived the Second war(correct me if I'm wrong)Maybe this is a sign that HoO is a children series(which it is ).If it was a series for older people,RR probably would've made the battle more ,epic and violent.I do not know how TLO is so good but BoO disappointing.HoH is one of the best written books RR has ever written.(if it isn't the best)How could BoO be so disappointing. Do you agree? What do you think ?