130 Votes in Poll
I haven’t read Magnus Chase but from Reyna seems super powerful. Plus she’s got her dogs so
Alex. If all special powers are allowed... would that mean the fight would take place in Valhalla? Alex might die, but she/he would just keep getting back up.
Does Alex get Pottery Barn? She'll probably still win without it with her shapeshifting.
There is a spoiler for Tyrant's Tomb in here. I think Reyna would win, I agree with @A Nerdy Fangirl but I have read Magnus Chase. And I think that would Valhalla count as a special object or power? It's not an object, and Alex only has that power of coming back again in Valhalla, but thats (sorry if this seems heartless) because Alex is dead. Also, if they were in Valhalla, wouldn't Reyna have to be dead or a Valkerie? (How do you spell Valkerie if you know what I'm talking about?) so Reyna couldn't be in Valhalla at all, so therefore she and Alex couldn't fight there. Though, @LatteBookworm I fully agree that in Valhalla, with Reyna being alive, and Alex keep coming back, Alex would win. But, you do have to consider Pottery Barn. With Alex's shapeshifting AND Pottery Barn, it seems pretty clear that Alex would win, but then you have to consider Reyna's dogs. They withstood (I'm pretty sure haven't read BoO in a while) Lycaon (might be spelled right, might not) and his wearwolves. They were beaten up badly, but still alive and fighting. (If you want the quote I can get it) I have nothing to say AGAINST Pottery Barn, just a lot for Reyna's dogs. Finally, I take in account Alex's shapeshifting. This power is extreme, and would definitely boost Alex, but Reyna is kind of used to dealing with stuff like this. And, with any animal claws or Teeth that Alex uses, Reyna has her cape. (unless you are talking about After she joins the hunters, then I guess she doesn't) Therefore, I think Reyna would barely beat Alex in a fight. Everyones Opinions are equally important, and if you don't agree with me, that's find, this is just my opinion.
Maybe I'm a little biased, but I feel like Reyna would definitely win without a doubt. Though Alex is well trained, the fight wouldn't be able to take place in Valhalla as Crunchywarrior said. I would say that as a whole Valhalla isn't an object or power. It's a place, so that wouldn't count. Reyna probably has more experience with being injured and weapons so that's another advantage of hers. I haven't read Magnus Chase and the Gods of Asgard in a while so probably need to re-read to make a better argument.
Misclicked meant to chose Reyna
Alex is the son/daughter of Loki the freaking god of mischief. Alex has pottery barn, her/his shape-shifting powers, and the fight could take place in Valhalla because Reyna can get in using the tree of life like blitz and hearth did, plus she/he has her/his weapon which can cut anything so it would be able to destroy Reyna's dogs which are only silver and gold. oh and remember Alex cut off a human head with her/his weapon(sorry i forgot what its called) that means, the weapon can go through flesh, bone and metal.oh yeah and Alex is immortal in Valhalla, however Reyna has been training her whole life and is in the hunters of Artemis(or would it be the hunters of Diana because she is roman?)she has her dogs but they would lose quickly. sorry if i sound biased.
The thing is, Reyna has an indestructable shield blessed by Athena, so....
Alex is well trained no doubt, she's had experience in fighting and her shape shifting powers are a real game changer. But we can't underestimate the effects of the disciplinary training at camp Jupiter. Also Reyna is very skilled in fighting, and she has her dogs and her Aegis. I think Reyna . But that's just my opinion.
What do you think?