Includes Kane Chronicle, PJO, HoO, MC. I couldn't recognize every single one of them so I guessed on some- but yeah...
'that dam snack bar!'
Fine, assuming what you say is valid, a 'hello kitty' tank top was (quoting jason) to look 'friendly and not wanting to kill the romans' even if she likes pink, people can change. and she is a bit different than the others in the aphrodite cabin, her life wasn't to pursue jason or something. yes, she cared deeply about jason but she wasn't speaking cheerleader on him.
Ok, yeah, and that. stereotypes. sure, piper is quick to stereotype but i think we all did that once in our life. even if piper is a bit flawed, she as written that way/misinterperated and overall she isn't horrible and deserves more credit than given.
I guess the most controversy topic of her is that she double standards. wearing pink does not mean liking pink. everyone thinks about boys (or opposite genders, idk) at least once in their life. the went through the trauma of hera-cheerokee-aphrodite love expectations and wanted her father to care more directly to her, even if he still loved her. i'm not saying tristan didn't like piper, but he gave his love in an indirect way making piper steal cars and chop her own hair off.
She was in the trauma of Hera-Aphrodite-Cherokee-Expectations
Why is Octavian in good?!
Frick, i didn't recognize that lmho- (some of them I can't distinguish)
Be careful of what you wish for...
Fr there's a reason why Rick wrote a idk 'boring' character in the 7 than have 7 people who all have similar arcs.
Rick wrote it in a way so that every character had some trait of diversity. If you don't like how one person is like, that's fine. Just imagine a book where every character feels and acts like Percy. Sure, it risks hate to have such a diverse topic of Piper, but I rather read a group of people with different opinions than 7 people with similar thoughts and preferences
Oh, that makes sense (i thought you were talking about the bmw from lost hero). That's true, during those events she was purposely controlling them-
But yeah, there are some main errors in piper that we can't gloss over in the fandom
This isn't a black-white thing, even if she deserves hate she deserves some credit, too.
Ah, ty @/InsertUsernameHereCauseIWhateverYourUsernameIsLol , i'll make sure to call on you when i need some help.
And for @/GraveDigger84 , your points are valid, but I was really just pointing out 'the good' (idk what's it called lmao-) of Piper, i haven't forgot about how Piper can be abit... yeah sometimes. I wrote thisbefore and am too lazy to rewrite it but possesive means not what it sounds like; "Possessive people worry that their partners will leave them. This creates feelings of fear, anger, and sadness. Trust is a vital aspect of a healthy relationship"
But yeah, Piper was worried about Reyna and Jason before they cleared the air between the 3. I guess you have valid claims about Aphrodite stereoptypical thingy, including Percy.
And for the charmspeak; she usuallly can't control it. For the BMW incident, before she found about her power, she had used it without knowing. She sometimes uses it without knowing, too, and she said that she would try not to purposley use charmspeak on them unless needed. Still don't know where that leads to, tho..
This is a hot topic now, lol.
So here's a teleporter:
NEUTRAL PIPER IDK: https://riordan.fandom.com/f/p/4400000000003439328/r/4400000000011642701
*sending virtual food*
Done and enjoy!!
Now back to the argument/war...
(this gives me reminders of my trauma in debate camp- s;fiojdsgi i spent 3 hours arguing with a girl about if cereal was a soup. fun times.)
I have bagels, chips, chocolate truffels, and some sPiCy salsa+chips-
Dont forget the jam
f they were truly friends, they'd spend time with each other instead of no interaction.
Hmm... if you were in the middle of a Roman x Greek crisis, it wouldn't be wise to start embracing Reyna or the Jupiter kids. And in the part in MoA (i think?) Piper personally chose Annabeth to go into the cave.
And about the possessive part; even if she spends a lot of time with jason, that doesn't make it possessive.
"We almost all feel some degree of possessiveness in romantic relationships. ... Possessiveness is fundamentally a fear of loss. Possessive people worry that their partners will leave them. This creates feelings of fear, anger, and sadness. Trust is a vital aspect of a healthy relationship"
Sure, she was worried about Jason and Reyna, but i think you misused it. you used it as putting all her attention on Jason and not the 7, but it's true that she was worried about Reyna until they cleared the air (Jason saying that she chooses Piper, not Reyna)
Piper can't control her charmspeak easily (sometimes she'll do it without knowing). She means that she won't forcefully use her charmspeak to her friends and group wtv willingly for her advantage, but she can use it sometimes without knowing (like how she stole hte BMW)
And for the part about attention, I meant as in she didn't like the attention from her dad because there was basically no attention and the small attention that she gave piper was small and a bit... bland (you could call it that? idk how to describe) I'm not saying that her father didn't care about her, though. care and attention are 2 different things, and I can vouch for that from my irl family