The most shocking part of this is that this hasn't been done before.
Reading Boy vs Most Powerful Magician In The World
Who will win?
^^^Oh wow. That is what I been saying for the past five days.
So take it from someone else, the secret name has nothing to do with combat.
^^Exactly.
Man, this is really hard! Both are EXTREMELY badass and powerful, in my opinion I think they're more powerful than each of the seven demigods(including Nico). If I have to choose I think Carter wins. More disciplined,stronger,smarter, and better in combat.
Why do some of you hate Sadie? I know there is a lot of you including me that loves Sadie, but I'm just curious.
If sadie uses carters secret name then she wins easily. But without that im gonna have to give it to carter. Not only is he excellent at combat magic but he can also create very powerful shields, use magic words and he has the crook and flail of ra which actually cut a rhino into 3 pieces long distant and managed to injure a full strength apophis (something even ra wasnt able to do). He would have natural resistance to all sadies spells and mind tricks. He is also better at shape-changing making him more versatile than she is.